IT Careers ·
Start With the Problem, Not the Tech: IT Leadership Lessons From Andrew Kirkwood
Bob Hansen
Most IT careers start with technology. Andrew Kirkwood's started on a restaurant floor.
Before he became VP of Technology at Shelby's Shawarma, Andrew was a general manager, a district manager and a franchisee onboarding specialist. That path gave him a habit every IT pro can borrow, from the help desk to the C-suite: start with the problem, not the tech.
On this episode of The Technology Vanguard [blocked], Bob Hansen and Andrew dig into the IT leadership lessons he learned moving from operations into technology, how his team uses AI to hear problems straight from frontline staff, and why the fastest way to grow in IT is to spend time outside of it.
From restaurant operations to VP of Technology
Andrew joined Shelby's in 2021, when the brand had 3 locations. As business development manager and franchisee onboarding specialist, he built the standard operating procedures, training, timelines and benchmarks for franchising, and helped open 12 restaurants. He touched everything from menu development and restaurant layout to technology and government compliance. At the time of the conversation, Andrew described about 50 restaurants across Canada and expansion into the US and the UK.
As the company grew, it split into departments. Andrew looked at where he could help Shelby's scale most, and the answer was technology. Third-party delivery, online ordering, apps, loyalty, kiosks and digital menu boards had become the foundation of the business.
He had no formal tech background, so he jumped in with both feet and learned everything he could. He also noticed that AI has leveled the field for everyone in the space: "We're all learning as we go."
IT leadership lesson 1: Start with the problem, not the technology
Andrew works backward. He looks for the problem the frontline worker, the operator or the guest is having, then asks whether technology can solve it. He does not pick a shiny tool and then go looking for a problem to point it at.
He also treats technology as only one part of the answer. Before any rollout, he asks 3 questions:
- Do we have the people?
- Do we have the bandwidth?
- Do we have the ability to implement it?
This applies to every IT role. A sysadmin choosing a monitoring tool, a cloud engineer proposing a migration, or a help desk lead pitching a new ticketing workflow gets far more support by starting with a problem the business already feels.
Adoption is the real test
Restaurants run on razor-thin margins, and most new tools add a cost that a franchisee has to accept. Andrew says franchisees only adopt technology when they see "really tangible ROI, daily tangible ROI." That is why a tool that solves 5 problems is much easier to roll out than a tool that solves 1.
IT leadership lesson 2: Let the front line tell you what's broken
Since COVID, Andrew says top-line sales have become harder to grow, so operational efficiency is where the return on investment is. His team uses technology to find that efficiency, while making it clear to staff that the tools are there to make their jobs easier, not to judge them.
One example is an AI-assisted camera system his team can query. Older systems could tell you how long a guest stood at the counter. Now Andrew can ask why: was the employee busy, was the store understaffed, or was the manager in the back room on their phone?
The bigger example started at MURTEC's Startup Alley, where Andrew met a startup whose microphone listened to conversations at the counter to analyze upselling and complaints. He told the vendor they were using about 5% of their technology. They pivoted.
Now staff can flag problems just by talking. Drive-thru headsets, the tablets used for inventory and checklists, and microphones at the front counter and in the prep area all feed one system. Nobody has to say a wake word. The AI decides whether someone was chatting with a coworker or making a real suggestion, then ranks the input: is this one person's preference, or is it happening at every location?
Every week, Andrew's team gets a list of opportunities, like a kitchen display screen that sits too far from the build station, too many steps to the prep area, or the most used ingredient stored on the top shelf. Andrew now sits on the vendor's client advisory board.
The lesson for IT teams: the people closest to the work already know what's broken. The job is to make it easy for them to say so, and to show them the outcome. As Andrew puts it, "If I can make their life easier, then they'll be much more willing to adopt it."
IT leadership lesson 3: Govern AI before it governs you
Andrew calls this the biggest problem in technology right now, across every type of business. Technology used to have built-in governance because it was hard to use. Now someone can find a new AI tool at 9:00 in the morning and, by 9:30, have put company information online with no governance or security.
The tools are incredibly effective, so banning them is not the answer. The question for every IT manager, security analyst and sysadmin is how to govern their use. A good place to start with your team: which AI tools are people already using, what data is going into them, and who approves a new one?
How to move into IT leadership: Andrew's career advice
Learn how the company makes money
Andrew believes many IT pros pigeonhole themselves with a "problem solver" mindset. "Understanding what actually makes your company money is probably the most important aspect of being a leader in your company," he says. His advice: spend time in marketing, finance and operations, learn their pain points, and ask what your role is in improving the business.
Ignore anyone who tells you to stay in your lane
The worst advice Andrew ever got was to stop thinking outside his own department. At the leadership level, he says, a breadth of knowledge across departments beats being an expert in only one.
Let people fail, inside a box
Restaurants run 7 days a week, and in a franchise system one broken system can cost thousands of dollars. So Andrew cannot simply let his team learn by breaking things. Instead, he lets people fail inside a box: real responsibility, good coaching, and room to win or lose where failure is safe. He calls himself a hands-on, hands-off leader, and he is clear that micromanaging never works.
Make decisions and own them
Andrew's advice for any IT pro who wants a seat like his is to stay open-minded in a world that changes minute to minute. "You don't have to be an expert, you just have to be able to make educated decisions and own the outcome of those decisions."
Key takeaways for IT pros
- Start every project with a problem the business already feels, then decide if technology is the answer.
- Before any rollout, check people, bandwidth and the ability to implement.
- Adoption depends on daily, visible ROI for the people using the tool.
- The front line already knows what's broken. Make it easy for them to say it.
- Shadow AI is a governance problem, not a reason to ban useful tools.
- To move into IT leadership, learn how the company makes money.
For another practical perspective on AI adoption and governance, read Enterprise AI Strategy: The 3-Legged Stool Every IT Leader Needs [blocked].
Watch the full episode
Find every conversation on the episodes [blocked] page.
Frequently asked questions
Who is Andrew Kirkwood?
Andrew Kirkwood is VP of Technology at Shelby's Shawarma. He started in restaurant operations as a general manager and district manager, joined Shelby's in 2021 when it had 3 locations, and helped open 12 restaurants before moving into technology.
What does "start with the problem, not the tech" mean?
It means finding the real problem a worker, operator or customer has first, then deciding whether technology can solve it. Andrew also checks whether the team has the people, bandwidth and ability to implement a solution before any rollout.
How can IT professionals move into leadership?
Andrew's advice is to learn how the company makes money. Spend time in marketing, finance and operations, learn their pain points, and build a breadth of knowledge across departments instead of staying only in your technical lane.
What is shadow AI and why does it matter?
Shadow AI is when employees use AI tools without IT's knowledge or approval. Andrew points out that someone can find a new AI tool at 9:00 AM and have company information online with no governance by 9:30 AM, which makes AI governance a priority for IT teams.
How is Shelby's Shawarma using AI in its restaurants?
Shelby's uses an AI-assisted camera system it can query about service delays, and a voice tool that lets staff flag problems by speaking into headsets, tablets or in-store microphones. The AI ranks the feedback and produces a weekly list of operational fixes.
Keep exploring
What should we ask our next guest?
Got a question for a future guest on The Technology Vanguard? Here is how to Ask the Vanguard:
- Open the latest episode on YouTube.
- Leave a comment that starts with "Ask the Vanguard:"
- Watch for your question in an upcoming interview.
New episodes drop every week.
The Vanguard Weekly
Get every episode summary in your inbox
Each week, get The Vanguard Weekly: the most valuable takeaways from every Technology Vanguard conversation in a 5-minute read.
Not connected. The REN AI signup connection is pending. This form is disabled and does not collect or send your information.
